Tip:
Highlight text to annotate it
X
Is waqt time hua hai 18:25 seconds.
Theek hai, app ka bohat shukria yahan mere saath ane ka. Kia app apna naam aur app kia kertay hain bata sak te hain?
Mera naam Alfred Kröner hai.
Mein university of Mainz houn jo maghribi Germany mein hai aur mein ek retired professor arziat houn
UK kay qanoon kay mutabiq mujhe app agha karna paray ga
Kay humari guftago record ki ja rahi hai, kia mujhe app ki ijazat hai kay mein is guftago ko khule aam dekha sakoon?
Bilkul!
App ka bohat shukria!
Mein app say sirf kuch sawal poochon ga, phela sawal jo mein app say pooch na chahata houn...
App wohi Alfred Kröner hain jo ek video mein aye the
jinhon nay Quran kay baray mein kuch tabsiraa kia tha, ye 70's kay akhir ki, ya 80's kay shuru mein tha
Kia mein app say pooch sakta houn kay kin halat ki wajah say app nay is conference mein shirkat ki thi?
Koi asay khas halat nahin thay. Ye ek mahirana conference thi jahan per kafi ghair mulqi
aur Arbi log mil rahe the kion kay ye pehli bar tha kay ek ahem
taftishi mansooba Saudi Arabia kia gaya tha
aur university of Jeddah, yani King Abdulaziz university nay dar asal is conference ki rah numai kee thi
kion kay ziadatar muqarar aur baday talib-e-ilm jo is university mein thay woh asal mein Britain aur maghribi European
mumaliq se padh ker aye the, aur wo apnay nataij dekhna chaha tay thay.
To kia ye conference khas tor per Quran aur mazhab kay baray mein thi?
Ya phir ye kisi aur cheez kay baray mein thi?
Is ka mazhab se koi talauq nahin tha, ye sirf ek mahirana conference thi arziat kay upar
Mazhab ya Quran kay mutaliq ek lafz bhi nahin kaha gaya tha!
To kia halat paida hue jin ki wajah se app ko mazhabi alfaz paish kiye gaye
aur phir uk ka tabsira kernay ka poocha gaya?
Well...
conference kay darmiyan ek Saudi Tv kay interview kernay wala aya tha is ka intezam us waqt kay
university kay vice president nay kia tha
aur us waqt taqriban panch ya chay,
Mujhay achi tariqay se yaad nahin araha, professors muqtalif
European aur shumali american universities se thay
Jinhon nay is TV interview mein shirkat ki thi
aur ye pheli dafa tha kay
humain in salawon ka samna kerna pada
"Quran kis hadh tak mojuda zameeni sciences kay mutabiq hai?"
App kay tabsiray ko bad mein asay pesh kia gaya tha ke app ye soch thay hain kay Quran mein asi maloomat hai jo us zamanay mein kisi insaan ko pata nahin ho sati theen
bina kisi khuda kay zahir kiye baghair
Kia app ye soch tay hain kay ye app ki us waqt ki ra-aye per sahih roshni dalta hai?
Dekhiye humara ye maqsad bilkul nahin tha aur jo mobahisah hum nay kia tha
wo mobahisah tha...
wo humain maqsoos Qurani ayat padh ker suna rahe thay aur phir wo yeh keh rahe thay
"Kia ye jadeed sciencei ilm kay saath muttafiq hai?"
Aur kuch jaga hum nay kaha haan, kion kay taqreeban har mazab mein asa hamesha kuch hota hai
jo muttafiq hota hai, aur kuch jaga him kaha "Nahin"
To is interview mein asa koi sawal hi nahin tha jis mein ye pocha gaya ho kia ye ke kia ye khuda ki waja se tha, asa kuch bhi nahin tha is interview mein
Kia app nay kabhi in videos ko internet se hata nay ki koshish kee hai?
Nahin
Asal mein, mein nay abhi ek cheez jani hai kuch arsa pehlay
kisi nay mujhe tofay kay tor per Quran dia tha
aur jasay he mein nay us Quran ko palat ker dekha to uskay peechay app thay, app asal mein mere Quran mein hain
Mein nahin janta agar app ko maloom hai, lekin app ek muqaddas kitab mein hain!
Mein ye dekh chuka hoon, aur mere pass ghar per ye kitab hai.
Mein nay isay kafi saal pehlay padha tha, lekin is ka humari us mulaqat se koi taluq nahin hai.
Kia app nay is waqiaye kay bad is baray mein agay tafteesh ke hai?
Nahin!
Aur kia app ki ra-aye is waqiaye kay baad se badal chuki hai?
Dekhiye, ye conference 79' mein hui thi mere khayal se aur kuch nahin hua tha aur
App ko pata hai kay sara internet ka mamla asal mein takreeban 4 saal pehlay utha tha shayad?
Mujhe to yaad bhi nahin hai!
aur phir mujhe kisi nay internet per peghaam bejha
aur mein nay jawab dia "Aray, mein to bohat heraan houn, lekin ye asa nahin tha" waghira
aur phir mujhe bar bar aur peghaam aye
aur phir mein nay apnay mahekmay kay logon say baat ki, humari yahan ek geography mahekma hai
wahan per do log hain jo asal mein Arabi bol nay walay Arabi hain
jesa kay app unko kahein gay, aur wo Arab dunia kay baray mein bohat achi tarhan se jante hain
aur mein nay unhay bataya is baray mein aur unhon nay kaha
"Dekhiye, app kuch nahin ker sak tay, app ko to bas isi kay saath rehna paray ga, app isay rehnay dein kion kay him app ko is baray mein kuck nahin bata sak tay. Kuch madad nahin karay ga"
Akir mein, kia mein pooch sakta houn, kia app is waqiye kay nateejay mein Muslman ho gaye?
Nahin, na mein is se pehlay kabhi musalman tha, aur na kabhi is bad!
[Dono hasne lage]
Akhir mein, is ko khatam karnay kay liye...kia app ye yaqeen dehani kera sak tay hain
Kia ye ra-aye jo app nay dee hai is video interview mein wo app ki apni hai?
Is video jis ke hum baat ker rahe nahin?
Jee, ye interview jo hum ker rahe hain is waqt!
Bilkul, ye meri apni ra-aye hai!
Aur kia main nay app ko koi inam dia hai is kay liye? Paisay ya kuch or?
[Haste huye] Nahin, abhi tak to nahin!
[Dono Alfred kay lateefay per has nay lagay]
Mein app ko kuch aur bhi nahin dene wala.
[Dono TheRationlaizer kay lateefa per has nay lagay]
Acha, Alfred app ka bohat shurkiya is interview kay liye razi honay liye
Mein ye koshish karoon ga gay ziyada say ziyada log is video ko apnay pass lagain.
Zaroor
Is waqt time hua hai 18:30 baj ker 39 seconds